Casting vs. Machining: How to Choose the Right Production Method for Your Custom Metal Parts Project

When it comes to creating custom metal parts—whether for automotive components, electronic devices, or industrial equipment—one of the most critical decisions you’ll make is selecting the right production method. For over 7 years, Shenzhen Sunmy Hardware Co., Ltd. (a leading custom parts manufacturer in China since 2016) has helped global clients navigate this choice, leveraging our expertise in both die casting and machining services. Many of our clients—from USA-based businesses seeking USA custom hardware parts to medical equipment brands needing precision components—initially struggle to determine if casting or machining aligns with their project goals. In this guide, we’ll break down the core differences between casting (especially aluminum die casting, our specialty as an aluminum die casting parts supplier) and machining (including CNC machining and lathe work), their respective strengths and limitations, and how to match each method to your specific needs.

What Is Casting, and When Should You Use It?

Casting—particularly die casting—is a manufacturing process where molten metal (often aluminum, zinc, or magnesium) is forced under high pressure into a prefabricated mold (called a “die”) to create complex shapes. Once the metal cools and solidifies, the die opens, and the part is removed (with minimal post-processing needed for some designs). At Sunmy, we specialize in aluminum die casting for clients needing automotive components customization and custom electronic components, as aluminum’s lightweight and corrosion-resistant properties pair perfectly with the die casting process.

Key Advantages of Casting

1.Ideal for Complex Geometries: Die casting excels at producing parts with intricate details—think hollow sections, thin walls, or integrated features like ribs or bosses—that would be difficult or costly to achieve with machining. For example, we recently worked with a European electronics client to create custom aluminum machining parts for electronics (wait, no—casting here: we produced aluminum housing parts with built-in ports via die casting, cutting their assembly time by 30%).
2.High Volume, Low Unit Cost: Once the die is designed and manufactured, casting scales efficiently. For projects requiring 1,000+ units (e.g., aluminum die casting parts for automotive sensors), the per-part cost drops significantly compared to machining, as the mold can be reused thousands of times.
3.Minimal Material Waste: Unlike machining (which removes material from a solid block), casting uses only the exact amount of metal needed for the part. This makes it a more sustainable choice for large runs and helps control material costs, especially for expensive metals.

Limitations of Casting

• Lower Precision for Tight Tolerances: While die casting can achieve decent accuracy (typically ±0.1mm for simple parts), it struggles with the ultra-tight tolerances (e.g., ±0.005mm) required for precision machining for medical equipment parts or high-performance industrial components.
  
• High Upfront Costs: Designing and fabricating a custom die is expensive (often $5,000–$50,000+, depending on complexity). This makes casting impractical for small-batch projects (fewer than 500 units) or prototypes.
  
• Material Restrictions: Not all metals are suitable for die casting. While aluminum, zinc, and magnesium work well, harder metals like stainless steel or titanium are better suited for machining (though we do offer stamping service for stainless steel brackets as a middle ground).

What Is Machining, and When Should You Choose It?

Machining is a subtractive manufacturing process where a solid block of material (called a “blank”) is cut, drilled, or shaped using precision tools—most commonly CNC machining service (Computer Numerical Control) for consistency.

At Sunmy, our machining capabilities include CNC milling, turning (for custom lathe parts according to drawing), and grinding, supported by a team that excels at translating client 图纸 (drawings) or samples into high-quality parts. We often use machining for clients needing custom lathe parts manufacturer services or precision plastic components (yes, machining works for plastics too, alongside our injection molding solutions).

Key Advantages of Machining

1.Exceptional Precision and Tolerances: Machining—especially CNC machining—is unbeatable for parts requiring tight accuracy. We regularly achieve tolerances as low as ±0.002mm for precision machining for medical equipment parts (e.g., surgical instrument components) and custom spare parts for industrial machinery, where even tiny deviations can cause system failures.
2.Flexibility for Small Batches and Prototypes: Unlike casting, machining has no expensive upfront tooling costs. This makes it perfect for prototyping (1–100 units) or small-batch production (e.g., a USA client needing 200 USA custom hardware parts for a new product launch). We can adjust designs quickly by modifying CNC programs, saving time and money.
3.Wide Material Compatibility: Machining works with almost any material—metals (aluminum, stainless steel, titanium, brass), plastics (for precision plastic components), and even composites. For example, we recently machined custom aluminum machining parts for electronics from 6061 aluminum, achieving a smooth surface finish (Ra 0.8μm) that met the client’s aesthetic and functional requirements.

Limitations of Machining

• Higher Unit Costs for Large Runs: Since machining removes material (often 30–70% of the blank), it’s less cost-effective for high-volume projects. A run of 10,000 aluminum parts, for instance, would likely be 2–3x more expensive with machining than with die casting.
  
• Slower Production Speed: Each part is crafted individually (or in small batches) via CNC tools, so lead times for large orders are longer than casting. For example, 5,000 custom lathe parts might take 4–6 weeks with machining, compared to 2–3 weeks with die casting.
  
• Design Constraints: Machining struggles with extremely complex internal geometries (e.g., deep, narrow holes or undercuts) that casting can easily produce. For such designs, we sometimes combine both methods: cast a rough shape, then machine critical surfaces for precision.

Real-World Example: How Sunmy Helps Clients Choose

To illustrate how these methods work in practice, let’s share a recent client case. A U.S.-based automotive supplier approached us needing 5,000 automotive components customization parts: aluminum sensor housings with external threads and internal cavities.
 

• Initial Consideration: The client first thought of machining, as they prioritized thread precision. However, with a volume of 5,000 units, machining would have been costly and slow.

  

• Sunmy’s Solution: We recommended a hybrid approach: use die casting to create the housing’s complex internal cavity (reducing material waste and unit cost) and then perform CNC machining service on the external threads to achieve the required ±0.01mm tolerance.
  
• Result: The client saved 40% on costs compared to full machining, received the parts in 3 weeks (vs. the 6 weeks machining alone would have taken), and the parts met all their automotive quality standards. This is how we blend our strengths as a die casting manufacturer and machining service provider to solve client challenges.

Sunmy’s Edge: Equipment, Quality, and End-to-End Support

No matter which method you choose, your project’s success depends on the manufacturer’s capabilities. At Sunmy, we stand out with:

• State-of-the-Art Equipment: For casting, we have 8 die casting machines (ranging from 160T to 800T) optimized for aluminum parts. For machining, our fleet includes 25+ CNC mills/turning centers (Haas, Fanuc) and precision lathes, enabling us to handle custom lathe parts according to drawing and high-volume CNC jobs. We also offer injection molding solutions for plastic parts and stamping service for stainless steel brackets to cover all your manufacturing needs (learn more about our full capabilities on our Production Capability page).
  
• Rigorous Quality Control: Every part—whether cast, machined, or stamped—goes through 5 inspection stages: 

  

  raw material testing (e.g., aluminum alloy composition checks), in-process monitoring (CNC tool calibration, die temperature control), post-production dimensional testing (using CMMs for precision parts), surface finish checks, and final assembly verification. This ensures your custom metal parts or precision plastic components meet ISO 9001 and your specific industry standards.
  
• Client-Centric Expertise: As a custom parts manufacturer in China serving global clients (including USA, Europe, and Southeast Asia), we understand the challenges of cross-border manufacturing—from design localization to shipping logistics. Our engineering team works with you from day one to recommend the best production method (casting, machining, or a hybrid) and optimize your design for cost and performance.

Conclusion: Which Method Is Right for You?

In short:

• Choose die casting if you need high-volume (1,000+ units) custom metal parts (like aluminum die casting parts) with complex geometries and can invest in upfront tooling.
  
• Choose machining services (especially CNC machining) if you need small-batch parts, ultra-tight tolerances (e.g., precision machining for medical equipment parts), or parts made from hard metals.
  
• For projects that need both complexity and precision, a hybrid approach (cast the base, machine critical features) is often the best choice—just like our automotive client’s success story.
   
  As a trusted aluminum die casting parts supplier and CNC machining service provider, Sunmy has the expertise and equipment to bring your project to life—whether you’re designing USA custom hardware parts, automotive components customization, or custom electronic components. To discuss your project and get a free quote, visit our Contact Us page or email our team directly. We look forward to partnering with you!

 website：sunmyhardware.com